Beanie Babies
Wish the Starfish
Wish the Starfish at a glance
Key details to help identify the version and understand its market value.
- Style
- 4594
- Type
- Starfish · orange
- Introduced
- March 31, 2003
- Retired
- February 26, 2004
- Swing tags
- Generations 7, 11
- Tush tags
- Generation 12
More about Wish the Starfish → Birthday, story, and every release.
$6
Median sold price
$0.25–$13.97
Observed sale range
How this price is calculated
Based on 18 matched completed sales. Prices vary by tag generation, condition, and listing accuracy. The full observed range is $0.25–$13.97, and the exact median is $6.12. Data updated Sep 21, 2026.
Estimated value over time
:
Recent sales on eBay
Completed eBay sales matched to Wish the Starfish · Style 4594
Report a data issue with this page
Some eBay links may be affiliate links. Sale prices shown are completed sales used for valuation research.
Current listings on eBay
Sep 25
These are current asking prices, not completed-sale values.
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission from qualifying eBay purchases, at no extra cost to you.
- Ty Beanie Baby - WISH the Starfish (UK TAGS)(7.5 Inch) MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy$16.95 View Ty Beanie Baby - WISH the Starfish (UK TAGS)(7.5 Inch) MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Ty Beanie Baby Wish - MWMT (Starfish 2002)$13.97 View Ty Beanie Baby Wish - MWMT (Starfish 2002) on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Ty Beanie Baby - WISH the Starfish (7.5 Inch) NEW MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy$16.00 View Ty Beanie Baby - WISH the Starfish (7.5 Inch) NEW MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- TY Beanie Baby WISH Starfish 2002$7.75 View TY Beanie Baby WISH Starfish 2002 on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Wish 2002 TY Beanie Babie 7in orange plush Starfish stuffed animal MWMT 4594$6.00 View Wish 2002 TY Beanie Babie 7in orange plush Starfish stuffed animal MWMT 4594 on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Ty Beanie Baby Wish - NEW$11.56 View Ty Beanie Baby Wish - NEW on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- TY Beanie Baby - WISH the Starfish (7.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy$9.99 View TY Beanie Baby - WISH the Starfish (7.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Ty Beanie Baby Wish The Starfish$5.50 View Ty Beanie Baby Wish The Starfish on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- VINTAGE TY BEANIE BABY WISH - STARFISH - MINT CONDITION - RETIRED WITH TAGS$150.00 View VINTAGE TY BEANIE BABY WISH - STARFISH - MINT CONDITION - RETIRED WITH TAGS on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Original Ty Beanie Baby "WISH" Starfish - 2002 11th/12th Gen Tags- Retired NWMT$13.00 View Original Ty Beanie Baby "WISH" Starfish - 2002 11th/12th Gen Tags- Retired NWMT on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Ty Collectible Beanie Babie Wish The Starfish 9" Plush$11.00 View Ty Collectible Beanie Babie Wish The Starfish 9" Plush on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
- Ty Beanie Babies Wish Starfish 2002 Retired Plush with Heart Tag$9.99 View Ty Beanie Babies Wish Starfish 2002 Retired Plush with Heart Tag on eBay (opens eBay in a new tab)
What can change Wish the Starfish's value
- Tag generation. Mint with both tags commands the premium, and an earlier swing-tag generation moves price more than condition does.
- Condition. Creases, stains, tag protectors and smoke exposure all show up in what buyers pay.
- Exact version. Pellet type, country of manufacture and renames make same-name toys different products at different prices.
- Listing quality. Most "error" listings describe common tag misprints that carry no premium; read titles skeptically.
About these prices
Values are based on completed eBay sales matched to this toy, not current asking prices.
How we calculate prices Hide calculation details
Included: Completed eBay sales matched to the toy and style number.
Excluded: Automated matching removes identifiable lots, cards, other Ty lines, reissues, and mismatched toys. Duplicate listings are collapsed. Some variation in condition or tag generation may remain.
How value is calculated: The headline value is the median sale price, weighted by units sold, with no outlier trimming. The observed range may include different conditions and tag generations.
Data updated